Contact Us  |  Locations

Baumholtz Plastic Surgery
4083 De Zavala Rd
Shavano Park, TX 78249
Phone: 210-880-3708


Saline vs. Silicone Implants – Which One is Better?

Breast augmentations, or boob jobs as they’re colloquially known, are one of the most popular cosmetic procedures. Today, you’ll find that the enhancement is safe, more accessible, and with outstanding results that achieve the desired look.

However, many women often don’t know where to start when considering breast augmentation. One of the primary factors is whether you should get silicone or saline implants.

Even though both implants achieve the same desired results, the look, feel, and safety of silicone and saline can differ. So that leaves the question, which one is better?

This article will review the most frequently asked questions about saline vs. silicone implants.

Let’s go!

Saline vs. Silicone Implants – What are the Differences?

The first question you may ask is, what are the core differences between the saline vs. silicone implants? While both function to achieve your desired breast shape and size safely, nuances between the two may make one implant preferred over the other.

Saline vs. Silicone Implants – Which One is Better?,

Find a description of each below.

Saline Implants

Saline implants are breast augmentation devices with an empty silicone shell inserted into a breast and then filled with sterile salt water to get the desired size and shape. The saline implant procedure has been used for around 60 years, uses a less noticeable incision point, and usually is less expensive than silicone.

Silicone Implants

In contrast, silicone implants are made entirely of the material, with their shell filled with silicone gel to simulate the feel of human fat. They come in various sizes and shapes, where the client can pick their preferred aesthetic. The procedure inserts them into the breast whole, albeit with a larger incision and at more expense.

Both implants are approved and considered safe by the FDA, pending the procedure being carried out by a certified surgeon. But what are the more in-depth details defining each implant?

Let’s have a look at the common queries below.

How Do the Implants Feel?

Silicone and saline implants have their unique feel. The former’s material makes the augmentation feel like a natural breast, soft to the touch. The latter is firmer, with the saline providing a more sturdy feel.

What Do the Implants Look Like?

The feel of both implants also correlates with the aesthetic of the breasts. Saline implants, being firmer, offer a round look that gives more roundness. Silicone implants will have a more natural aesthetic, given that the material is more aligned with human fat.

Is the Procedure Different for Each Implant?

One of the most notable differences between the two implants is the procedure used for breast augmentation. They are placed in different manners because of the way each implant functions.

Silicone implants are pre-filled, requiring a larger incision to fit into the breast, and may be more noticeable on the skin. Saline implants are filled after insertion, leaving a less prominent, smaller incision.

How Durable is Each Implant?

Both saline vs. silicone implants are safe and each relatively durable as each other. They are designed to last a very long time, though getting check-ups on your implants every couple of years is recommended.

Saline vs. Silicone Implants – Which One is Better?,

You may need to replace your implants further down the line to reassure them of their integrity.

What Happens If They Rupture?

Implant ruptures don’t often happen, especially with the quality of materials and procedures from certified breast augmentation surgeons. However, it’s possible breaks could occur in both silicone and saline implants.

If a saline implant ruptures, the fluid can be safely absorbed into the body. However, silicone implant ruptures may cause issues, especially for those with autoimmune conditions. Should you seriously consider breast augmentation surgery, it’s essential to consult with a specialist to understand the risks that both implants can pose.

Is One Implant Better Than The Other?

There’s no definitive answer to whether saline vs. silicone implants win as a better option for breast augmentation. The client’s choice depends on the results they look for, their expressed concerns, and possibly budget and accessibility.

One specific factor is that prospective breast augmentation clients want to consult a surgeon to understand the process and implants. Working together will bring confidence and assurance about which implant is right for you.

Should you need profound and expert advice about breast augmentations in San Antonio, TX area, contact Baumholtz Plastic Surgery for a consultation. The physicians will be able to provide a comprehensive review of your desired look and the best process to achieve those results.

Comments are closed.

irma gamboa
irma gamboa
My tummy tuck journey began about 3 1/2 months ago when I had my 1st office visit with Dr. Baumholtz. Dr. Baumholtz listened to what I wanted had done, he gave me his professional opinion and his recommendations and said “yes we can do it”, never pressured me to move forward with procedure, he told me when your ready you let me know. Dr. Baumholtz is an amazing Plastic Surgeon. I’m exactly 10 weeks post op - tummy tuck today, 3/18/22, I could not had asked for more, my results are amazing and could not be any happier. Dr. Baumholtz and his staff to date have gone above and beyond with my after care, they are always their for you and you are not left alone. Renee works with Dr. Baumholtz, she is very knowledgeable and always has an answer for you. Also, where I had my surgery was at emerge plastic surgery specialty center, awesome nurses and staff, always very attentive to me before and after surgery, facility was amazing. Thank you Dr. Baumholtz, you are awesome and thank for all you have done for me, I feel like I’m on top of the world. Anyone trying to get any plastic surgery procedure, go see Dr. Baumholtz, He WILL take care of you, he is awesome. 10 weeks ago today, 3/18/22, I’m amazed and beyond thankful, I’m just so happy with my tummy tuck.
Krystal Ausmus
Krystal Ausmus
The entire staff is amazing and everyone at the surgical center is attentive, kind, and very professional. Such a great experience!
Merlinda Valdez
Merlinda Valdez
There are so many reasons why I am extremely happy with Dr. B's work; one word keeps popping up is AMAZING. Dr. B performed a breast reduction and it's been several years that I have not felt this AMAZING physically and mentally. Dr. B thank you and your staff (especially Renee) for providing the most AMAZING service with honesty, availability, and making me feel safe. I would recommend all day everyday. TOP NOTCH SERVICE.
Kriezl Gutierrez
Kriezl Gutierrez
Dr. B and his team made my experience very comfortable. I was well informed even with my own research and they are available to you pretty much 24/7. Anytime I had a question , I was able to get an answer within the same day. I’m very happy and pleased with my results!
Valerie Zamora
Valerie Zamora
Super happy with my results! Doc was super nice & loved the 3D imaging to see what my possible results could be! 10/10
veronica duran
veronica duran
I couldn’t be any happier with my results!! The entire process was such an amazing & positive experience and one I will never forget. I was treated like a person rather than a number. Everyone, from the staff at Dr. Baumholtz’s office to the staff at the surgical center were so comforting and reassuring. Renee and Katherine at the office have been more than great, and the surgical center staff were so professional and caring. All my questions & concerns were addressed and I felt like part of a family. Thank you to all who were involved on my journey!!
Emma Cantu
Emma Cantu
Mommy Make-Over. Tummy Tuck/Breast Lift Best Plastic Surgeon! Dr. Baumholtz is highly regarded as an excellent surgeon among his peers in the medical community. Every expectation of my procedure was met and exceeded. After meeting different surgeons , I chose Dr. Baumholtz because he was the MOST honest about managing my expectations, and of course because of the fact that he is a highly skilled board certified surgeon! Trust your surgeon - Thank you Dr. Baumholtz and staff !
Lisa Rivera
Lisa Rivera
Dr.B is amazing. He will answer any questions you have, he will not pressure you to make a decision your not ready to make. Going to Dr B was the best decision I made! My results are beyond what I ever imagined! Dr B has the best bedside manner! I was nervous about my breast augmentation but he put me at ease and made me feel comfortable! I would recommend him to anyone! (Which I already have) Staff is also very professional and friendly! I love Dr B and his staff!